Synopsis
In the magical small town of Moonshine Hollow, Rosalyn has everything she thought she wanted — a thriving teashop, enchanted pastries, and her glitter-sneezing caticorn, Sprinkles. But what she really craves is a romance as heart-melting as her baking. Enter Bjorn, a rune elf with devastating charm and a hidden royal identity. Tasked with helping a wild unicorn herd plagued by chaotic magic, Bjorn finds himself reluctantly teamed up with Rosalyn. As they race to solve the magical mystery, forced proximity turns into sizzling tension, and both discover that love might just be the most powerful magic of all.
Detailed Review
Must Love Scones and Secrets is the literary equivalent of a warm pastry fresh from the oven — sweet, comforting, but with a dash of heat that takes you by surprise.
Maisy Magill has woven a cozy fantasy romance that balances whimsy and steam to perfection. The small-town magic of Moonshine Hollow feels lived-in and welcoming, with quirky shops, eccentric townsfolk, and the perfect dash of magical creatures to keep things lively.
Rosalyn is a delight — warm, witty, and unapologetically herself. Her enchanted scones aren’t the only thing irresistible about her; she radiates a joy that even Bjorn’s frosty reserve can’t resist. And speaking of Bjorn — hello, swoon central. The grumpy/sunshine dynamic between him and Rosalyn crackles on the page, with banter that had me smiling and romantic tension that had me flipping pages far past bedtime.
The magical mystery surrounding the unicorn herd adds a satisfying layer of plot, keeping the story from being only about romance. It’s well-paced and engaging, giving the characters opportunities to work together (and, naturally, grow closer).
And let’s talk spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️ — Magill writes with a playful yet passionate touch, ensuring the romantic payoff is as delicious as promised. Fans of cozy fantasy who also crave a touch of heat will find this the perfect balance.
This book is the perfect winter-night read — or any time you want to escape into a world where love is magical, pastries are enchanted, and even unicorns have a little drama.
About the Author
Maisy Magill is a cozy romantasy author known for blending whimsy, warmth, and just the right pinch of spice. Her Moonshine Hollow series invites readers into a magical small town filled with quirky residents, enchanted bakes, and heart-stealing love stories.
Books Similar to This One
- That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon by Kimberly Lemming
- Emily Wilde’s Encyclopaedia of Faeries by Heather Fawcett
- Of Goblins and Gold by J. Penner
- A Deal with the Elf King by Elise Kova
Spice Rating
🌶️🌶️🌶️ (Medium) — Passionate kisses, sensual scenes, and romantic heat that’s more than a tease but still wrapped in warmth.
Why You Should Get a Copy
- Grumpy/sunshine dynamic that actually delivers the chemistry
- Magical animal companions (a glitter-sneezing caticorn? Sold.)
- Cozy fantasy vibes with a hint of mystery
- Perfect balance between slow-burn romance and satisfying payoff
Interactive Quiz: “Which Moonshine Hollow Role Would You Have?”
Question 1: Your ideal magical pet would be…
A) A glitter-sneezing caticorn
B) A wise old owl who dispenses life advice
C) A shapeshifting fox
D) A tea-brewing fairy
Question 2: Your dream job in a magical town?
A) Baker at the enchanted teashop
B) Keeper of magical creatures
C) Potion shop owner
D) Bookshop & gossip central manager
Question 3: How do you handle drama?
A) Bake something sweet and talk it out
B) Investigate until you have all the facts
C) Use magic to make things right
D) Laugh it off with friends over tea
Results:
- Mostly A’s: You’re the heart of Moonshine Hollow — people come to you for comfort and advice (and snacks).
- Mostly B’s: You’re the town’s protector, always stepping in to help — even if it means getting your hands dirty.
- Mostly C’s: You’re the problem-solver with a touch of mischief, keeping life interesting for everyone.
- Mostly D’s: You’re the social glue — you know everyone and everything, and you love it that way.
Call to Action
💌 Love this blog? Support my work and keep the bookish magic going!
Reading Caffeinated 